I began reviewing books in my teens, albeit science fiction ones, but have covered the crime genre without a break for the past 32 years, beginning with a monthly column in TIME OUT LONDON for 11 years, followed by a 12 years stint for THE GUARDIAN and then LOVEREADING and for almost a decade now here at CRIME TIME. I have loved praising great books and writing, supporting authors new and old. At a rough guess I’ve reviewed over 3,500 books in that lengthy period! But all good things must come to an end, and this is my final proper column. Ageing eyes slowing down my reading, some measure of disillusionment with the shifting nature of the publishing and writing ecology and the fact that for the past 3 years, I have also returned to editing (hence an even larger reading burden) all of which factors have led me to throw down the towel, albeit with much sadness in my heart. I’ve also noticed that my reviews were increasingly becoming pernickety and maybe on occasion unkind, and I don’t wish to be remembered as an ungrateful sod! You won’t get rid of me totally, though, as the team at CRIME TIME have agreed that I will be allowed to make parsimonious returns with the occasional solo review if a book enthuses me enough, but no more covering 10 titles a month! There will be a valedictory column next month, not discussing new titles (there are few books published in December) but highlighting a handful or so of novels which, because of possible conflict of interest, I have been unable to champion here but, in my view, deserve a better place in the sun. It’s been an interesting journey…
BOOK OF THE MONTH
Nick Harkaway/THE TAPER MAN (Viking)
When Nicholas Cornwell, who previously wrote daring and innovative SF extravaganzas as Nick Harkaway, took over the mantle from his late father John Le Carré and returned us to the shadow world of George Smiley and his Cold War corridors of deceit with KARLA’S CHOICE, it was so much more than an act of chameleon-like imitation and proved a worthy tribute to a particularly unique fictional territory that no one has equalled. Could he continue in that vein? The answer is a massive YES as THE TAPER MAN brings Smiley back in a complex case set between some of the previous books in the series, just following on from THE SPY WHO CAME IN FROM THE COLD. Unobtrusive, quiet, mischievous and a man of so many secrets, Smiley returns to the Circus following the shooting of agent Roy Bland in Helsinki in 1965, and the death of what was possibly a double agent, a case that evokes the possibility of a Russian deep cover agent at a high level of the American intelligence apparatus. Despatched to Washington DC, Smiley’s benign questions and inoffensive demeanour disarm the officials he calls on but nonetheless sets a cat among the pigeons as he threads a tortuous way towards the final revelations. The appearance of other protagonists from the Smiley/Karla novels and the reader’s knowledge of their ultimate fate and motivations adds wonderfully to the texture of this impeccable novel. The legacy is assuredly in the right hands.
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
Kate London/BLACK EARTH (Firefinch)
A gritty social realistic police procedural that begins with a family tragedy and the disappearance of a young boy in a mining village in the Midlands in 1959 alongside a tragic fire, that ends up defining the future lives of some of the novel’s protagonists in this initial volume of a new series by former police Chief Constable Kate London, to follow on from her gritty novels featuring Collins and Griffiths which began with the acclaimed POST MORTEM. Flash forward to 1984 and DC Ian Weldon is now a local cop in Staffordshire, following a stint in the serious crime squad in Liverpool, his life still under the dark shadow of the earlier tragedy, while his brother Stephen is on the front line of the miner’s strike in Stoke. When Stephen’s son disappears, echoing the sad events of a quarter century earlier, the two brothers are drawn back together in a case that could easily tear their bond apart and reopen delicate old wounds. As the novel swings between periods, each new section offering fresh insights into the deadly secrets the brothers and their friends harbour, we are presented with an exemplary X-Ray of British working-class society past and the ties that bind families together and can as easily tear them asunder. Sad, powerful and affecting, this novel tackles, despite its roots planted firmly in the past, problems that are still at the forefront of policing today: homophobia, race relations, corruptions in high places, drugs and their movement across county lines. A rather essential read.
Ian Rankin/THE HEIGHTS (Orion)
It’s been almost twenty years since Ian Rankin wrote a book not featuring Rebus and his acolytes, and this new effort, currently a stand-alone but with the potential of developing into a series, is solid if a bit underwhelming. Maybe the fact that Abir Mukherjee’s recent THE PINNACLE also features murder and dark shenanigans in a luxury apartment tower too, but with the added bonuses of a turbocharged plot set in teeming India, has stolen some of his thunder? The Heights is the bijou in developer Allan Franklyn’s possibly teetering empire, and he occupies the penthouse while an assortment of entitled characters, all with secrets to hide, populate the lower floors, including the project’s architect, a pop star, an art dealer, a foreign heiress, a gangster’s wife alongside too many still unoccupied apartments. When the body of the building’s concierge is found murdered and all CC camera footage excised, ambitious Detective Sergeant Gillian Gish is early on the scene and although her superiors would rather she not meddle, is determined to unravel the web of lies, connections and past murky events clouding the crime, with invisible links wrapped around the characters. Her partner DI Jack Milton is approaching retirement and tempers her efforts, but she is driven by both ambition and the fact she is in dire financial straits and makes the case something of a personal crusade, with a nearby journalist lurking with whom she illegally shares information in a bid to move forward. The plot is complex and ticks along with clockwork precision, but too many of the characters are a touch caricatural and the novel lacks immediacy. Will Rankin stay on Gish’s case and write about her again and provide a better set of villains?
Sam Tallent/BRUT (White Rabbit)
Tallent might be a leading US comedian with a glittering track record and tons of encomiums, but his attempt at a tongue in cheek noir thriller is a total mess. I don’t think I’m being a purist and don’t believe hardboiled tropes are certainly open to an injection of humour and self-referential elements, but I was already on the wrong side of the fence when the protagonist is introduced as Robert Beaujolais. And I’m not even a wine snob! The said unlikely-monikered Beaujolais is a hitman working for a mysterious boss known as Uncle and after a botched job is despatched to Paris where a rich man’s daughter has paid for the killing of Massimo, an organised crime leader. Mayhem of course ensues. Sadly, this not a light as a feather Donald Westlake-like caper but a book where the author is all too serious and skirts parody with interminable purple prose and descriptions with a tsunami-load of over-stretched similes amongst the extreme, graphic violence, actual hints of racism and a distinct impression that he feels he is God’s gift to writing. But Tallent is no Hemingway, and at best the novel might work as a comic strip scenario where at least the style would be restricted to speech bubbles. You’ll be right in assuming it wasn’t my cup of tea, and more like a sip of past its selling date vinegar. Oh, dear!
Jo Nesbo/KILL SHOT (Harvill)
The 14th Harry Hole thriller and the first in the bestselling and popular series in some time sees a disillusioned, grizzled Harry initially working as an insurance investigator after leaving the force. When a series of crimes disturb Oslo’s community, it’s Ole Fauke, his beloved stepson and now a cop, who finds himself assigned to the investigation and soon drags Harry back into the fold as a consultant. It appears a serial killer is on the loose, specifically targeting people involved in FINAL CUT a past, never-completed movie and despatching them in a cinematic manner, beginning with a prostitute Felicia whose demise is both gruesome and actually filmed. Each new murder that occurs confirms the connection to the unfinished film, repeating inventive murders that formed part of its scenario, as a contractor, an actress and a loan shark in turn reach their violent demise. As ever, Harry has to juggle the labyrinthine case alongside a messy private life, involving stepson, son and an assortment of women with ambiguous attentions, although he appears to have cut down on the alcohol, but still remains something of a haunted character. Despite the massive length of the novel, the pace never falters building a spider’s web of existing connections between past and present with meticulous precision, as dogged Harry pulls the strings together. A classic fallible hero for the ages who is always welcome back.
Andrew H. Murray/EVERYTHING HAPPENS SO MUCH (Orion)
A venture into whimsical fantasy with a heart by British broadcaster Andrew Hunter Murray, whose earlier books had been somewhat high concept thrillers, flirting gently with the liminal reaches of fantasy. Esme Good is an inoffensive nobody with a nothing job on a complaints hotline in some anonymous city but has the opportunity to depart reality temporarily by drinking The Elsewheres, some special potions, that allow her to become a better version of herself, a superhero by default. This, until she unwittingly becomes the most important person in the world and mayhem promptly follows, with touches of Douglas Adams and Terry Pratchett-like humour tempering the SF tropes. Esme’s regular quarter of an hour escapades into alternate realities where she is both glamorous, sometimes even married, wealthy and free from drudgery do however bring her to the attention of a shadowy governmental organisation the FRA, the Fabric of Reality Authority. The zany action unfolds fast and furiously although I wasn’t sure if the first-person narration was the right medium and fails to evoke enough sympathy for the accidental heroine’s plight and the whole farrago moves perilously close to accelerated levels of zaniness, and although billed as life-affirming, just feels a tad too caricatural. A pleasant distraction, but no more.
Lilja Sigurdardottir/ALFA (Orenda)
Another instance of an author best known for gritty thrillers taking the high road and moving into the realm of speculative fiction, Icelandic powerhouse Lilja Sigurdardottir’s ALFA sees her enter the realm of literary dystopia and gets it right from the outset. It’s Reykjavik in 2052, and the world is at relative peace with conflicts abolished and crime free, if only because ALFA, a mighty AI oversees matters. Only for Birkir, an obstinate dissident intent on living outside the system to be murdered. He was the brother of Sabina, an artist who is married to Mekkin, an important cog at the Ministry that oversees the AI system that regulates everyone’s lives, with their son Julius turning 16 and about to be ‘microchipped’ and his future fully mapped out and controlled, as others’ lives have also been regulated in the current utopia. The crime, however, proves there is a dark side to the society they have happily been living in and Sabina’s dogged investigation is soon causing friction at home and in the higher spheres of power, and likely to reveal the rot in the system. Both an exemplary crime thriller and a deft insight into an unlikely future regulated by AI, ALFA grips like a vice by focusing on the familial ties that bind when they happen to come up against an immovable social structure. Gripping.
Frederick Forsyth & Tony Kent/THE ODESSA ASSASSIN (Bantam)
Despite Forsyth’s passing, the franchise continues with British lawyer and writer Tony Kent at the helm, although it feels uncertain how much of the plot might have been outlined by Forsyth, unlike the direct sequel to the original issued as THE REVENGE OF ODESSA last year. Having by the skin of their teeth somehow destroyed the German assets of the resurgent Nazi group, the valiant Peter and Georg Miller and their fortuitous Israeli and British allies, have now become a target for the American-based and deeply entrenched arm of the organisation and a target for revenge by the indestructible twin brother and principal assassin of one of its former leaders, now with an added appetite for savage revenge. A complex plot to assassinate US president and have him replaced by puppet politicians of a Nazi persuasion unfolds at lightning pace with a brilliant set piece in a sports stadium eerily reminiscent of a recent apparent attack on Trump, but the novel then bogs down into a frustrating, if breathless, cat and mouse game with superficial characterisation but plenty of bodies as the good guys (and token gal) skirt annihilation on every street corner and the US Secret Service teams are overtaken by traitors, bar a handful of good guys who will inevitably save the day. Almost an action film script ready made for the screen, but sadly all too implausible and laden with clichés.
Peter Grainger/THE KINGS LAKE INVESTIGATION SERIES (Penguin)
Grainger is one of the many self-published and suspiciously prolific authors who have for several years been churning out novels and gained a respectable audience through sheer force of numbers. Like L.J. Ross and others, this has not gone unnoticed and sees him now picked up by a major house, in this case Penguin, who are re-releasing all 17 of his existing DC Smith Kings Lane series in one full swoop in the hope of increasing his already substantial audience. Talk about market saturation! I don’t wish to sound bitter, but this is yet another factor that has progressively led to my increasing tiredness in reviewing. I’ll quickly state that there is nothing wrong with Grainger’s British rural crime procedurals (and he has another series on the go, featuring the Willows and Lane duo); they are decently written, earnest, even display some touches of humour but in no way are they innovative and just, so like so many other current series the book market is swamped over with, merely spin familiar variations on plots and types of characters we have seen too many times before. Is this what readers deserve? Should we not be offered even a modicum of originality? Penguin have done a great job with the reissues: uniform cover art and a strong marketing outreach, but I must question the intentions as a publishing tsunami of this kind will just be denying bookstore space to so many other titles, books that are at least trying to offer the readers something new and taking risks in the process. In sorrow.
Cate Quinn/BEFORE I DISAPPEAR (Sourcebooks)
A perfectly adequate memory loss psychological thriller, professionally written and paced, and providing an abundance of twists in its concluding stages, Cate Quinn’s novel is a typical example of the type of novel the publishing industry, both in the USA and the UK, is content to inundate the shelves with, and which have certainly contributed in the last decade or so to progressively weaken my interest in the genre and, finally, led me to give up reviewing on a regular basis (this being in all likelihood the final review of my 30 years or so stint…). Now, I know that every book written is a labour of love for the author and aware of all the sweat and tears it generates in the effort, but where Gillian Flynn’s GONE GIRL was innovative and felt like a tonic refreshment of a sub-genre which Patrica Highsmith and Ruth Rendell magisterially made their own, and I know that I’m being unfair to Quinn, this is just another drop in an ever-expanding ocean; shelf fillers with limited ambitions which the reading public is still inexplicably lapping up (viz Freida McFadden’s success); thrillers by numbers but lacking soul. April Anderson, a woman with a professional background as a criminologist wakes up in a hotel room, under the protection of the police, with her memories erased and must contend with filling in the vital gaps in a complicated case involving family ties, and dastardly secrets in which she finds herself a vital witness. I know I’m being totally unfair to the author by picking up on her book and using it as a sort of loss leader for all that is presently wrong in the thriller field, but it just happens to be a November 2026 title and was the first one in the heaving pile I picked up; I’m confident there are better and worse examples. And the title was just perfect for the occasion!
So that’s it for me.
Vale.


