The fashion for creating new sleuths based on real life personalities continues with the introduction of Lord Byron and C.S. Lewis to the sleuthing firmament, and both actually fit in surprisingly well! A month that also delivers locked room/locale mysteries, thrillers in a futuristic environment, a coruscating look at female friendships under pressure, serial killers in their natural American habitat, a new Terra Alta investigation and so much more; something for every criminal taste.

 

BOOK OF THE MONTH

Essie Fox/DANGEROUS    (Orenda Books)

A truly sumptuous historical mystery novel by an author already acclaimed for her previous ventures into past times, DANGEROUS features Lord Byron in detecting action amongst many real-life characters from his period. Taking place in Venice where Byron is in temporary, disgraced exile and the object of both fascination and envy in view of his extravagant and often scandalous activities, it sees him become entangled in the happenstance of various local women being murdered with deep gashes to their throats. Feeling a veil of suspicion falling over him, if only because a booklet titled THE VAMPYRE has fraudulently been published under his name, he has to turn detective to prove his innocence. In reality the short tale was written by his friend Dr. John Polidori, albeit based on a tale initially read out by Lord Byron by Lake Geneva, in which Mary Shelley’s FRANKENSTEIN also came to literary life. The gothic and deeply atmospheric tale that ensues proves both fascinating and suspenseful, evoking the famous poet and the magic but dark side of the city in the lagoon with sharp acuity and supreme elegance, as befits both the famous Lothario and poet and a city that keeps on inspiring writers to this day by its beauty and underlying sense of depravity. The sybaritic Byron jumps out of the page with gusto as his investigation unveils dark corners and the more shadowy side of some of the characters he shares the pages with. A thing of beauty aided by the fact that the book’s lay-out, production and cover are so wonderfully attuned to the subject and enhance the pleasure of reading it.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

Tariq Ashkanani/THE MIDNIGHT KING    (Viper)

An impressive breakthrough of a novel on his 3rd outing for the author of the much-awarded WELCOME TO COOPER, this high-octane thriller manages to breathe fresh blood (so to speak) into the tired grooves of the serial killer novel. The action is set in the USA  between 1994 and 2008 when thirteen children from the Nashville area are killed in succession by a fiend the press baptise the Music City Monster. However, it is revealed from the outset that the monster responsible is none other than Lucas Cole, a bestselling celebrity writer, a father and widower, and the story develops with his confession. However, Lucas is now dead and his son Nathan, who had known of his father’s misdeeds since the age of 10 and accordingly fled the region, has now returned 17 years later to his home town and comes into possession of the manuscript, hidden in a cabinet with sordid trophies, in which the self-proclaimed Midnight King reveals all the ghastly details of his criminal activities in a final manuscript not meant for publication, including clues to the fate of a child who had disappeared just a few days before his death. Forced to confront the evil, Nathan must also attempt to find the child, if they’re still alive, and beating a private investigator hired by the missing girl’s family on the same trail to it as he himself is concealing certain secrets he wishes to be kept in the dark. Bleak, uncompromising and with some shocking twists in the tail, this is a powerful punch to the gut and a memorable achievement.

 

Alafair Burke/THE NOTE    (Faber & Faber)

When three successful professional women whose friendship goes back many years decide to organise a reunion on a long weekend in a glamorous holiday let in the Hamptons, the veteran mystery reader will  expect the inevitable tension and jealousy, but Alafair Burke’s wicked psychological thriller still manages to come up with many surprises. Soon to be married May Hanover is a half-Chinese under-achieving lawyer who has taken refuge in academia; Lauren is slightly older, a black woman who has become a famous musician while Kelsey, the rich Golden and often irresponsible Girl has survived the unresolved death of her husband. When a drunken prank ties them embarrassingly to the disappearance of a wealthy scion, the tensions between the group heighten to perilous level, as all three have hidden secrets and then begin to suspect each other, all the while under the sharp scrutiny of a local policeman whose initial suspicions are soon proven right and the trio, torn asunder, begin to incriminate each other. Burke weaves a mischievous web, moving the reader’s sympathy away from one woman to another as she unpeels the layers of their shady past, uncovering untoward events and a previous mysterious death at a summer camp years earlier, with direct ties to the present case they have become entangled with. Impeccable, original plotting and a peach of a mystery, with my only reservation being the fact that all the characters are somewhat unsympathetic and overly bitchy. Did Burke originally plan matters that way but it will be a (minor) drawback for some.

Nick Harkaway/SLEEPER BEACH    (Corsair)

I was terribly impressed by the way Harkaway, John Le Carré’s youngest son, took over his father’s universe in KARLA’S CHOICE, a mightily different sort of book to those SF-inspired tomes he had previously been known for, as well as the frantic Aidan Truhen thrillers he’d penned under a further pseudonym which I found much less convincing. He now returns to the future world of TITANIUM NOIR, taking its protagonist Cal Sounder back to his roots as a detective now that he has reluctantly accepted the G7 drug treatment he was wary of in the preceding volume and become a Titan, a form of genetically-enhanced human giant in a society sharply divided by the haves and the have nots, where only the rich can afford to transform themselves in such manner. Hired by Martha Erskine, one of the wealthiest Titans, he travels to the crumbling seaside port of Shearwater where a woman’s body has washed up on the beach. In true dogged Philip Marlowe style, Cal is soon bruising his way through much intrigue and opposition from the powers that be when his investigation leads him to suspect a strong link to a local, powerful factory on the outskirts of the beach and he happily treads on too many toes for comfort. In truth, a traditional tale of hardboiled sleuthing, with a main character all obstinacy and guile, this doesn’t add too much to the canon, despite its futuristic trappings and a lead character with an almost Marxist view of society. Overall, a slight disappointment as I was hoping for less detection and more SF elements after the fascinating premise set up by the first novel in the series.

Javier Cercas/FORTRESS OF EVIL    (Maclehose Press)

EVEN THE DARKEST NIGHT, the first in acclaimed Spanish literary novelist Javier Cercas’ Terra Alta crime series had a density often absent from most mystery books, and dollops of atmosphere and intrigue. It introduced rogue book-loving cop Melchor’s travails in a very particular area of Catalonia. I was one of the judges who awarded it the CWA Dagger for Crime in Translation. The second volume in the series PREY FOR THE SHADOW lacked the strong narrative drive of the initial instalment and proved a disappointment. Sadly, the latest book FORTRESS OF EVIL confirms the decline of the series and marks no improvement. Melchor is now a librarian bringing up his daughter Cosette, so named after the character in LES MISERABLES, which Melchor had read in prison in his earlier incarnation as a criminal. When she is abducted on a holiday in Mallorca, Melchor sets on the war path and aided by an assortment of present cops, retired ones and other jailbirds seeks revenge on the powerful industrialist responsible. The narrative plods endlessly, the metafictional elements Cercas introduces whereby Melchor’s investigations are now the object of bestselling books by none other than a certain Cercas, which he refuses to read but which the other protagonists have, prove too much a nod and a wink to the reader as if saying ‘don’t take this too seriously’, a clumsy attempt at topicality drawing on the Me Too movement albeit on a Spanish level, and too many far-fetched developments, as well as tons of exposition about the variety of Spanish police jurisdictions, all weigh the book down heavily. Add the uncomfortable endorsement of vigilante law and the novel never comes to credible life. I’m unsure I will read another Terra Alta book should any be written. Such a pity!

Kelly Mullen/THIS IS NOT A GAME    (Century)

A quirky variation on Golden Age locked room mysteries with a modern zest of eccentricity and humour, US author Kelly Mullen’s debut is very much a crowd pleaser in the mould of the KNIVES OUT movie series. Crotchety septuagenarian widow Mimi lives on an isolated island where cars are not allowed and cocktails at all hours almost an obligation. Her estranged granddaughter Addie is nursing her grievances having been not only dumped by her fiancé but also booted off their fledgling video game company which she was instrumental in running. However, her work developing a murder mystery game will come in highly useful! When the pair are invited to a charity auction event by local socialite Jane Ireland and the party is isolated by a major storm during which Jane is found murdered, the ill-matched pair of grandmother and daughter manage, despite evident strains, to pair up and sleuth away, with indications of blackmail, extramarital affairs and all the petty sins high society normally conceals soon seen as triggering motives for the case they are facing, which is naturally followed by yet another dead body. With much sardonic dialogue and a winning combination of amateur detectives, this variation on a theme by Agatha Christie (and a zest of John Dickson Carr) aims to entertain and does so splendidly and augurs well for further outings by this duelling pair of unlikely detectives.

Maureen Paton/THE MYSTERY AT RAKE HALL    (Swift Press)

A debut novel by a veteran non-fiction author, THE MYSTERY AT RAKE HALL resurrects another real-life figure and sends him on his investigative way, as noted academic and writer of the Narnia books and classic science fiction C.S. Lewis is reimagined as a period detective. Lewis was an Oxford don at Magdalen College in 1947 and also a friend of Dorothy L. Sayers, a crime writer whose relationship with Christianity was, like his, important in their work. Paton extrapolates a case where Susan Temple, a brilliant student of his takes refuge in a hostel for unmarried mothers, shunned by society following a drunken encounter which has left her pregnant, and then falls out of sight. Teaming up with Lucy Standen, a friend of the missing student whose father is a porter at the university, he begins to ask awkward questions. In the immediate aftermath of WW2, Britain was still rife with prejudice and a thriving black market and Lewis was but a cloistered academic not necessarily inclined to delve deep into such realistic matters and the amateur sleuths come to uncover much in the way of disagreeable truths. Paton, whose mother was actually also a one-time boarder at Rake Hall when she was pregnant with her and single, brings academic circles and post-war Oxford to vivid life, including insights into the now-famous Inklings group which J. R. R. Tolkien was also part of, and ‘Jack’ Lewis and Lucy make for a determined sleuthing duo. A good start for a new series.

Jo Callaghan/HUMAN REMAINS    (Simon & Schuster)

The eagerly awaited third instalment of the award-winning Kat and Lock mystery series, in which the aforementioned DCS Kat Frank once again races down the investigative trail, aided and abetted by AIDE, the world’s first AI detective, a pilot programme which the single, widowed mother is nurturing. A fascinating blend of almost science fiction and thriller elements, even though much of the technology Callaghan presents is already available and in existence, framed in everyday life as the Future Policing Unit has to deal with one, then two headless bodies on a Warwickshire farm, bringing undue attention to the past case of the Aston Strangler which Kat had thought resolved and now has to shoulder the possible blame for. The matter soon becomes highly personal when the working equilibrium between her and Lock, who is visible to her as a hologram, becomes tainted and both parties are puzzled as to whether they can even trust each other. In parallel, Kat has to deal with the emotions that having her only son now away at university make her face while her unit is understaffed and under threat. The case is unrelenting and proves a race against time and the odds, with all the human characters splendidly etched while the suspense and unlikely twists ratchet up the emotions and make for a must read. Though penning a book (and series) involving AI and the far reaches of science, Jo Callaghan never allows the human factor to steer out of reach and the results prove deeply satisfying (and with a formidable, surprise conclusion…).

Ron Currie/THE SAVAGE, NOBLE DEATH OF BABS DIONNE    (Atlantic Books)

An ambitious and at times highly evocative and powerful thriller by a journeyman US literary talent, this is a no holds barred chronicle of a life of crime fully assumed, featuring the eponymous Babs Dionne, the matriarch of a French Quebecois gang in Waterford, in rural Maine. She is a doting grandmother but also a merciless all-woman mafia boss, responsible for the flow of drugs into Little Canada. Struggling to hold her slum empire together and under threat from a higher-level crime overlord who has sent an emissary known only as The Man to investigate her activities, she is assisted by her older daughter Lori, an ex-military Afghanistan commando but also a junkie fighting her addiction. Then her younger daughter Sis coincidentally goes missing and is later found dead and Babs’ fury is mercilessly unleashed. A bleak evocation of small-town blight in a French Catholic half-Canadian society, where pills, booze and junk are rife, the novel never shies away from depicting violence, abuse and sheer psychopathic evil unleashed while combining the tensions of family drama and a fast-moving, suspenseful plot with women pulling the dirty strings. The book often feels as if it’s taking place in the Depression era but small details keep on reminding the reader it’s set in modern times, demonstrating that human nature has little changed since those grey days, or at any rate in rural Maine. The characters don’t go out seeking the sympathy of the reader and their ferocious and uncompromising actions often make them unsympathetic and probably true to reality; yet more evidence that crime is a dirty, unglamorous business. Powerful stuff.

Claire Anderson Wheeler/THE GATSBY GAMBIT    (Renegade Books)

Now that F. Scott Fitzgerald’s fascinating classic has entered the public domain, we are being deluged with variations, sequels, musicals and unashamed appropriation of some of its unforgettable characters. First to enter the fray was Michael Farris Smith’s estimable NICK in 2021 which, although penned by a crime writer, veered away from mystery but THE GATSBY GAMBIT is an outright murder mystery set at the time of the events of the novel in the 1920s, introducing Greta Gatsby, an imagined sister to the seductive Jay, an orphan under the benevolent protection of her brother in his West Egg Mansion where she circulates amongst Nick Carraway, the Buchanans, Jordan Baker and other characters from the original novel, seeking a purpose in life in opposition to all the glamorous frivolity surrounding her. When a guest is found dead on Jay’s luxury boat, Greta now finds her destiny as a sleuth, becoming an ersatz younger version of Miss Marple in search of clues and a diversity of motives, sharply disagreeing with the police who think it is a suicide. Both a homage to the glittering world of Fitzgerald’s book and a hardy attempt at penning a Golden Age mystery in a familiar fictional upper-class world, this is a fast and breezy read with no other purpose than entertainment. And what is wrong about that? A most pleasing debut from a new American author who, interestingly enough, has a book publishing background.

ADVERT